SeedSigner Review
DIY air-gapped signing device you build yourself for under $100, designed for multisig and maximum supply-chain trust.
Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Why We Recommend SeedSigner
SeedSigner represents a fundamentally different approach to hardware wallet security: instead of trusting a manufacturer's supply chain, you source commodity Raspberry Pi components yourself and flash open-source software that anyone can audit. The entire codebase is free and open-source with reproducible builds, meaning you can verify the binary you're running matches the published source code. Communication happens exclusively through QR codes—no USB, WiFi, or Bluetooth connections exist on the recommended Pi Zero 1.3 board—creating a true air gap that's physically verifiable rather than promised in marketing materials.
The stateless design eliminates one of hardware wallets' biggest attack vectors: there's no seed stored on the device to extract. Seeds exist only in RAM while powered, then vanish completely when you turn it off. You regenerate your keys each session from your backup (typed words, dice rolls, or SeedQR cards), which means a stolen device reveals nothing. Independent security reviews confirm private keys never touch companion software, and the project publishes PGP signatures and SHA256 checksums for image verification. For users who understand the model, this provides security guarantees that even expensive hardware wallets with secure elements cannot match—though it demands more user responsibility.
Best For
Bitcoiners building serious multisig setups who want to eliminate single-manufacturer risk. If you're creating a 2-of-3 vault using devices from different vendors (say, Coldcard, Passport, and SeedSigner), you've ensured no single company's compromise can threaten your funds. The QR-based PSBT workflow integrates smoothly with Sparrow, Specter, and other multisig coordinators, making SeedSigner an ideal co-signer in these configurations.
Technically-minded users who value transparency over convenience will appreciate building their own signing device from $50-150 in parts. You control the entire supply chain: buy a Pi Zero from any electronics retailer, inspect the board, flash the verified image, and you have a signing device with no proprietary firmware mysteries. This appeals to cypherpunks, security researchers, and anyone who's uncomfortable trusting that their hardware wallet wasn't intercepted or tampered with before delivery.
Educators and Bitcoin developers also find SeedSigner valuable as a learning platform for understanding PSBTs, key derivation, entropy generation, and air-gapped signing workflows. The explicit entropy requirements (dice rolls or camera noise) force users to understand randomness, and the stateless model teaches proper backup discipline. It's not the right choice for beginners wanting plug-and-play simplicity, but for those willing to invest time understanding Bitcoin security, it's an exceptionally powerful and affordable tool.
Services & Features
Considerations
Requires technical comfort with DIY assembly, image flashing, and entropy generation—poor dice technique or rushed setup can compromise security. The stateless design means re-entering your seed every session, which adds friction compared to stored-seed devices.
